If you look at their career winning percentages, both Carr and Winston are historically more reliable winners than Dennis Allen as a HC. I strongly believe Winston is a much better QB than DA is a coach. However, Carr is historically a bit better than Winston, and we gave Carr a guaranteed $30 million salary for 2024. Also, there is no salary cap for coaches and they salaries are small compared to players, a new coach would cost us less than Ruiz or Granderson. Maybe less than Juwon Johnson. It makes the most sense to replace the coach who is historically worse than Carr or Winston, has had more than twice as many games here to prove himself, and is financially easier to replace, and to see how Carr does with different coaching, and if Carr goes down how Winston or Haener does. I hope Haener is the next Brock Purdy or whatever but the odds are strongly against it. The hit rate on mid to late round QB's becoming stars has to be something like 1 in 20 and nobody in our building has identified a diamond in the rough at QB in 17 years. If there is any chance to keep any QB healthy it involves improved oline play, and against the cheapest possibility for improving oline play is new coaching.