Question for the Forum: Who was the worst Saints player during your lifetime?

[WhoDat!656]

I’m going to say Brandon Browner

[MatthewT]

I'm gonna roll with Heath Shuler

[BakoSaint]

I think the players who did the most harm were Nick Fairley and Alex Analzone because they were on the cap/roster during the key window years for winning a title when we just needed a little more defense and caused major holes. Fairley had a known heart condition, committed elder abuse against the GM and owner to get a bug contract, then before the ink was dry on the contract saw their own specialist and was put on bedrest for the length of the deal while we missed Superbowls and Conference Championships by one score in OT. Analzone held down a starting job for all those championship window years with mediocre play and flashes while the musical chairs his constant injuries causes prevented the defense from ever getting in a rhythm until he left the team. They say the greatest ability is availability so I think those two were the worst. If we passes on Fairley and got Suh we might have had a ring or two.

On the current team I would say Trevor Penning. We nuked the entire offense and have every target focus on blocking not getting open to cover for starting Nancy Kerrigan at Left Tackle early this year. Meanwhile the 2023 1st we traded to Philly as only part of the package to get a second 1st to take Penning was used to trade up one spot for Jalen Carter the probably DROY at DT. The Bears took the original pick and selected Darnell Wright who was a 17 game quality starter. Penning is likely to cause chaos on the roster for years to come as we waste time trying Nancy Kerrigan at RT or OG.

[neugey]

Jason "toast master" David

[SmashMouth]

Originally Posted by neugey

Jason "toast master" David

This one got me banned from another site when I dared to state that he sucks and sucked. Silver lining is that it got me here.

[AsylumGuido]

Trevor Siemian - recently

Jason David - in the past - to be fair, though, he was that square peg being forced into the round hole

Honestly, there are no doubt dozens more over the years that have been far and away worse than anybody mentioned and it's impossible to judge any player whose Saints career has yet to be completed.

[BakoSaint]

Originally Posted by SmashMouth

This one got me banned from another site when I dared to state that he sucks and sucked. Silver lining is that it got me here.

OMG they kicked you out for criticizing Jason David? I think Andrus is on Mickey Loomis’ payroll or gets some special access and priviledges for favors. That other site really flaunts copyright with its use of the Saints name, logo, and images everywhere compared to other sites. Did you know Andrus has a criminal record?

[SmashMouth]

Originally Posted by BakoSaint

OMG they kicked you out for criticizing Jason David? I think Andrus is on Mickey Loomis’ payroll or gets some special access and priviledges for favors. That other site really flaunts copyright with its use of the Saints name, logo, and images everywhere compared to other sites. Did you know Andrus has a criminal record?

With what I know he did with his attempts on this very site, it doesn't surprise me one iota.

Once Halo upgrades BnG, we should see some very nice transformative tweaks and an influx of new and/or returning family members. BnG needs to be a bit more internet 2025 friendly.

[Crusader]

Originally Posted by neugey

Jason "toast master" David

He wasn't very good for us but I have to say I respect the man. He always gave it his all.

[lee909]