I lived in NY Giant country for three years. I now live in Falcon country, temporarily.

I listened to a LOT of NY sports talk radio during my time there. The case of Eli Manning WAS a divisive issue last year, BUT, this year, it seems like the Giant fanbase is largely down on Eli Manning.

Let me say right now that I like the entire Manning family. Deuce and Archie are the best Saints ever in my book. I want Eli to succeed with the Giants.

That said, in my opinion, it's clear that the Giants made a bad deal to get Eli. They could have drafted Ben Roethlisberger without making the Eli trade.

I have another opinion. Remember when Archie and Eli went public with their intent to avoid playing for the Chargers? That has backfired. Archie and Eli made a mistake. By pulling that stunt, they upped the ante for Eli, and put A LOT of pressure on Eli to produce immediately. The Giants overpaid for Eli, and that's why the Giant fanbase have turned against him rather quickly.

YOUR THOUGHTS, PLEASE. I respect your football knowledge and opinions. Let us know what you think about this.

Thanks.