What's that? An Aaron Brooks thread?

[baronm]

trust me eli will be a better qb than brooks.

look lets\' compare similar styled qbs--brooks and lets say farve-farve plays with just as bad a defense and a worse offensive weaponry..but maybe a better line.

what seperates farve from brooks-they both have great athletism, both can run, both have a good arm..it\'s leadership and that is my biggest complaint about brooks is that he is not a leader..partly becasue he is unacountable for his actions and partly because he is a self-centered player..

team wins and stats do not neccessarily go hand in hand.look at manning-great stats, can\'t get them over that hump.

farve is a HOF qb because he is a leader.

[GumboBC]

Of course Gumbo would call you fair

saintwhodi --

To you, NO one is fair uless they are willing to agree with you about Brooks.

I can post stats, win/loss records, etc.,ect., for other QBs first 4 years and show you they were worse than Brooks. And those would be QB who went on to win the super bowl.

Not that those \"Stats\" would prove anything. But YOUR stats prove NOTHING either. Brooks has very good \"stats\".

I really don\'t think you want to go down the \"stat\" road for QBs. Let me know if ya do though.

[saintswhodi]

Gumbo, please tell me what \"stats\" you are talking about? Are you talking about the stats I and then mutey showed you about those 5 QBS YOU NAMED that were better than AB\'s? You mean those stats? Please. That argument was over as soon as you made it. Green blew AB away with worse weapons, so did Culpepper, so did Bulger, so does anyone. If you love Brooks, I am happy for any and all who are. Enjoy him. Please don\'t cry on here next year when we see the same thing, or if he is holding out for more money in the off-season. I am truly done.