A player with 66 catches for 888 yards and 4 TDs is not a project. Carr and Smith may be projects, but the Saints signed Meredith with a specific role in mind and film proving his skill set.

I think Beastmode just can't admit to being wrong. Its a very common thing.

People on NFL boards get wrapped up in all the off season garbage and imagine themselves to be competent GM's. The emotional investment in their imaginary expertise spills over into this sort of rancor during the regular season when the ACTUAL team management does something that doesn't jive with the imaginary brilliance on the boards.

Tiring to say the least but it isn't going to stop anytime soon.

A player with 66 catches for 888 yards and 4 TDs is not a project. Carr and Smith may be projects, but the Saints signed Meredith with a specific role in mind and film proving his skill set.

On a 3 win team. Is CM better than Pryor? He had over 1,000 yards that season and look how that turned out. Another situation of a bad team with one WR that gets all the mop of targets they want. Hurns, same thing.

On a 3 win team. Is CM better than Pryor? He had over 1,000 yards that season and look how that turned out. Another situation of a bad team with one WR that gets all the mop of targets they want. Hurns, same thing.

Just keep repeating the same old lame logic over and over again. As long as you believe it ... which I doubt. I'll guarantee you that almost everyone else thinks it's crap. Meredith was brought in for one reason and one reason only, to take over the slot duties and he has already been a success in doing that.

It will be clear in the next 3-4 weeks how things will shake out. Notice I did not revert to name calling or laughing at you. I also don't make bets hoping for other players to fail which you did. If you lose the bet I also will not laugh at you. It's petty and just not what I do. I look at the facts and accept them. 3 games in and Carr, Smith and CM each have one single catch. If you want to call CM the winner and superior talent then go right ahead. I don't know who will win the job right now. That is exactly what I said at the beginning of the season and is exactly what happened. He is also not the WR2. That would be Ginn. It's actually Kamara but technically it is Ginn.

I don’t get where Beast is coming from. To say we don’t need more receivers on the field producing is stupid. I just don’t think Meridith is the answer. He had one reception that was a TD. I’m happy for him and wish him the best. I hope he is great for us but I don’t see it happening.