Loss to pats on Payton and Brees

blackangold · 10-14-2013, 01:16 PM

Originally Posted by WHODATINCA

Talk about mental error. <eyeroll>

2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael.

2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael.

Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton.

Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays?

WHODATINCA · 10-14-2013, 11:54 PM

Originally Posted by blackangold

2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael.

2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael.

Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton.

Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays?

Hmmmm...good points. I just remember the losing. Retracted. Apologies.

blackangold · 10-15-2013, 01:34 PM

Originally Posted by WHODATINCA

Hmmmm...good points. I just remember the losing. Retracted. Apologies.

No problem.

I had no intention of being harsh.

Welcome to the forum!

TheOak · 10-15-2013, 02:33 PM

Originally Posted by blackangold

2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael.

2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael.

Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton.

Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays?

If I remember correctly, Pete Carmichael didn't start calling plays until Sean broke his knee in 2011 and that was only until Sean returned to the field. Then he was the only man in 2012. As far as for 2012 there was some seriously questionable play calling going on, search these forums..

Who called the plays that led us to a Super Bowl and won it? Sean Payton

You didnt like the play calling at the end of the game? What would you do with no Graham and no Sproles at the end of the game?

Let the man do his job... he has earned the right to be human once in a while.

blackangold · 10-15-2013, 03:08 PM

Originally Posted by TheOak

If I remember correctly, Pete Carmichael didn't start calling plays until Sean broke his knee in 2011 and that was only until Sean returned to the field. Then he was the only man in 2012. As far as for 2012 there was some seriously questionable play calling going on, search these forums..

Who called the plays that led us to a Super Bowl and won it? Sean Payton

You didnt like the play calling at the end of the game? What would you do with no Graham and no Sproles at the end of the game?

Let the man do his job... he has earned the right to be human once in a while.

Carmichael called the plays all through 2011 after the Tampa game. 2012 our offense was #2 in the league. Not discrediting Payton at all, but after the Tampa game Payton said he was rusty and might turn the play calling over.

Payton has had great calls in the past; its unfathomable that he has been so good. Although there seems to be some disconnect this year. We have so much talent at WR but our WRs as a group are statistically among the worst in the league right now. There could be many reasons for this but I don't have the answers.

10-14-2013, 01:16 PM	#1
blackangold 1000 Posts + Join Date: Aug 2011 Posts: 3,422	Re: Loss to pats on Payton and Brees Originally Posted by WHODATINCA Talk about mental error. <eyeroll> 2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael. 2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael. Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton. Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays?

10-15-2013, 01:34 PM	#3
blackangold 1000 Posts + Join Date: Aug 2011 Posts: 3,422	Re: Loss to pats on Payton and Brees Originally Posted by WHODATINCA Hmmmm...good points. I just remember the losing. Retracted. Apologies. No problem. I had no intention of being harsh. Welcome to the forum!

10-15-2013, 02:33 PM	#4
TheOak 10000 POST CLUB Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Cypress Tx. Posts: 19,043	Re: Loss to pats on Payton and Brees Originally Posted by blackangold 2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael. 2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael. Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton. Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays? If I remember correctly, Pete Carmichael didn't start calling plays until Sean broke his knee in 2011 and that was only until Sean returned to the field. Then he was the only man in 2012. As far as for 2012 there was some seriously questionable play calling going on, search these forums.. Who called the plays that led us to a Super Bowl and won it? Sean Payton You didnt like the play calling at the end of the game? What would you do with no Graham and no Sproles at the end of the game? Let the man do his job... he has earned the right to be human once in a while. Boutte likes this.
	It's not what you look at that matters, it's what you see. ~ Henry David Thoreau Last edited by TheOak; 10-15-2013 at 02:36 PM..

10-15-2013, 03:08 PM	#5
blackangold 1000 Posts + Join Date: Aug 2011 Posts: 3,422	Re: Loss to pats on Payton and Brees Originally Posted by TheOak If I remember correctly, Pete Carmichael didn't start calling plays until Sean broke his knee in 2011 and that was only until Sean returned to the field. Then he was the only man in 2012. As far as for 2012 there was some seriously questionable play calling going on, search these forums.. Who called the plays that led us to a Super Bowl and won it? Sean Payton You didnt like the play calling at the end of the game? What would you do with no Graham and no Sproles at the end of the game? Let the man do his job... he has earned the right to be human once in a while. Carmichael called the plays all through 2011 after the Tampa game. 2012 our offense was #2 in the league. Not discrediting Payton at all, but after the Tampa game Payton said he was rusty and might turn the play calling over. Payton has had great calls in the past; its unfathomable that he has been so good. Although there seems to be some disconnect this year. We have so much talent at WR but our WRs as a group are statistically among the worst in the league right now. There could be many reasons for this but I don't have the answers.

LinkBacks (?) LinkBack to this Thread: https://blackandgold.com/saints/61166-loss-pats-payton-brees.html
Posted By	For	Type	Date	Hits
Loss to pats on Payton and Brees	This thread	Refback	10-13-2013 06:54 PM	54

10-14-2013, 11:54 PM	#2
WHODATINCA Site Donor Join Date: Aug 2013 Location: South Bay Posts: 3,784	Re: Loss to pats on Payton and Brees Originally Posted by blackangold 2011 who called the plays that lead to a historical offense? Carmichael. 2012 who called the plays for the offense that lead the league (offense that was good enough to have a 7-9 record with the worst Defense in the history of the NFL)? Carmichael. Who said that if his play calling doesn't get better he will turn it over (to Carmichael)? oh yeah, it was Payton. Are you new, or do you not realize how well our offense has functioned when SP hasn't called the plays? Hmmmm...good points. I just remember the losing. Retracted. Apologies.