halloween 65

I have to agree with you. Some games he played were far from the word "Elite".

TheOak

Drew being 4th is correct. Drew being = to Rapestburger kills all of his credibility.

Danno

Very true, but that's two separate discussions.

Adam Shein is an entertainer, and a pretty good one. I love his show.

NFL expert analyst? Not so much.

AlaskaSaints

And if we play the same offensive play book next year, Drew will fall further down the list.

Quality coaches see right through Drew.

We had better bring a stepped up game next year or we will be in decline.

Alaska

lumm0x

Adam Shein is not entertaining. When I hear "lotta pop, lotta sizzle" I want to punch through my Sirius radio. He is a mouthpiece with little to no knowledge of the game. Contradicts himself constantly and is nothing more than fluff on the radio. I'm glad he's off the Sirius NFL channel now.

As for Brees, my opinion is he is right about 4th at this time in his career. There are times he was the best and most season he's been in the top 3 mix. He will be a first ballot HOFer and he is a top 10-15 QB all time. Anyone who ******* about that doesn't remember our team history and has become spoiled.

papz

pumpkindriver

Schein has a NE bias, always has, always will. Glad he is off the NFL channel and on the clown channel known as Mad Dog radio. Hes very good at getting people riled up so they will call into his show but no one should ever take his opinions too seriously b/c they are calculated to piss you off.

OldMaid

Reagarding this Adam, Schein,
what the hell is he talking about?

He is simply a talking head who would rather than say something really truthful that requires thought and would be thought provoking and have him stand alone against his colleagues, he says the same ole stupid stuff of elite qb's.

What makes one an elite qb?
It is the overall, total,complete career.
DBrees fits that.
I am not saying this because I am a DBrees fan.
Jim Kelly was even though he never won a SB.
Bret Farve was and I never liked him.
Kurt Warner was not even though he won a SB.
Eli Mannig is not even though he won two SB's.
PManning IS AN ELITE QB even though he lost two SB's.
Archie Manning is not and was a not a great qb either.
Sorry.
Just for example. I was just watching a Mannig show on HBO. It was really good.

darksoul35

Lets give all the other QBs the starting left tackle Brees had most of the year and see if they can even walk again. More less put up the numbers that he did.

Mardigras9

His interception rate was so high the year he didn't have a coach because he was throwing all the time just trying to keep them or get them back into the game.
Drew is an elite QB and future hall of fame player. Doesn't matter to me if he is #1 or #4, he is our guy and I wouldn't trade him for any of the other "elite" QB's on the list.