Something Positive about Brooks. I must be insane.

saintfan · 04-09-2005, 09:38 AM

Uh, yeah I disagree

Why am I not surprised.

you have refused to suggest that his often poor and inconsistent play affects them.

This couldn\'t be more inaccurate. I do not refuse. What I do is point out, for example, that a pass doesn\'t have to be perfectly thrown to make it catchable. You, however, do seem to suggested that Brooks is the primary reason our team hasn\'t performed up to expectations.

You say that the QB rating is meaningless

Nope. This isn\'t true. What I DO say is the QB rating is the result of things often out of the control of the QB. An example of this would be a catchable pass dropped by a WR. Does Brooks throw some bad passes. Of course. Does he throw passes that should be caught but are dropped? Well, I think he does. Once again I\'m sure you\'d disagree.

You want to blame AB\'s low efficiency on the rest of the team. I want to blame it on him.

The big difference between you and me, Whodat, is that you want to blame it ALL on him and I think the blame should get passed around to ALL those responsible.

04-09-2005, 09:38 AM	#39
saintfan Donated Plasma Join Date: Jul 2002 Location: San Francisco, CA Posts: 18,556 Blog Entries: 5	Something Positive about Brooks. I must be insane. Uh, yeah I disagree Why am I not surprised. you have refused to suggest that his often poor and inconsistent play affects them. This couldn\'t be more inaccurate. I do not refuse. What I do is point out, for example, that a pass doesn\'t have to be perfectly thrown to make it catchable. You, however, do seem to suggested that Brooks is the primary reason our team hasn\'t performed up to expectations. You say that the QB rating is meaningless Nope. This isn\'t true. What I DO say is the QB rating is the result of things often out of the control of the QB. An example of this would be a catchable pass dropped by a WR. Does Brooks throw some bad passes. Of course. Does he throw passes that should be caught but are dropped? Well, I think he does. Once again I\'m sure you\'d disagree. You want to blame AB\'s low efficiency on the rest of the team. I want to blame it on him. The big difference between you and me, Whodat, is that you want to blame it ALL on him and I think the blame should get passed around to ALL those responsible.
	C'mon Man...