Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

Good grief. I didn't get anything of that nature from his post.

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

If you would take time to go back and look, the person I was debating (Thirty3) was giving college performance as support. I only went back to point out there was nothing in that realm that gave any support to Hill being superior to Winston. I know as well as anyone that college performance means little in the big leagues.

So, do you personally believe that Hill is definitely a better NFL QB going forward than Winston since you are chiming in? How about a yes or no and then why you believe that?

Well?

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

And we stress a small sample size for Hill with half his games started against one of the worst defenses in the NFL in Atlanta and another against a team without a QB on their gameday roster. The other team he faced had was a loser in the worst conference in the entire league ... and he lost to them.

Sorry, JP. You have to have more ammo than that sorry crap.

Anything else?

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

I’m not following that logic. One of Winston’s 4 first games in his rookie season was a Win against the Saints where he had a QBR of 114+. The Saints had a better record that year than any of the teams Hill beat last year. Now, that performance is better than anything Hill has done so, by your reasoning, Winston has a higher ceiling because he had a higher QBR in one of
his first 4 starts than Hill did in any of his first four starts. Hill also has never had a 3 TD, 400 yard passing game before...Winston has. Winston’s 4 best games are better than Hills 4 best games. So, how does Hill have a higher ceiling?

And how do you know we’ve seen the best Winston has to offer? Tampa has not been a historically successful franchise and where you say a 40 YO QB took his team to the SB I can say it took the future HOF/winningest/best QB to ever play the game to unseat him. You don’t think a 27 YO QB could get better playing under Payton? Brees did.

And I will repeat that I am not pulling for either player. Makes no
difference to me who emerges as starter. I hope and expect them to produce. I am just surprised at the willingness some have to write Winston off as done. Multiple HOF QBs have demonstrated worse years than Winston has produced. But, oh well. Time will tell.

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

My comprehension is quite strong, thank you. He has had coming up on four years worth of snaps in practice to be accessed. That's where most QB's are accessed. When on a roster the QB deemed the better starter under the circumstances will get the starts. Due to Winston's short time in the system that was Hill last season. Now the most prepared will start in 2021. My hopes are that it will be Winston because it makes the team better as whole and that's what's most important, don't you think?

Or is that not important to you?

When and IF Hill does gain enough confidence from an NFL coaching staff to become a full-time starter the rest of us will see what it is you claim he has going for him. THAT is a big if in my opinion.

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

There will be a QB competition and there will be a winner, one will lead the team from the huddle an QB position. The other will lead the team in positions played and critical contributions in all facets of the game, offense, pass catching, running, blocking and special teams with occasional wildcat formations. Discussion and opinions while interesting in the forum discussion simply do not accurately track the coaching staff’s process and decision made around the QB position this past offseason.

TH showed he has the arm and athleticism but could not process the defensive coverages, his receiver reads and ending up looking indecisive and holding the ball too long getting sacked or worst yet fumbling the ball way to frequently.

They brought JW back and gave him prove it money to be “The QB” not to be backup, drafted Book to hopefully be the #2 QB so TH can do what he does best to help THE TEAM WIN.

Not a betting man ... but I will hold fast to this position.

Re: Taysom Hill: “Really nice” to tailor all offseason work to playing QB
 

Agree 100%! That will all make the Saints a better team on offense and special teams than they would be with Hill under center and Winston sitting the bench.