Trever Siemian is the guy. He got inserted into the middle of the game, played pretty well considering, and we came out with the win. He just looks better than Winston... looks over the field better and everything. He just needs some practice with the first string. We have a very complicated offense, and some of the mistakes he made were on timing routes and things that can be fixed. A week or 2 of practice and we got someone that I feel can lead us. I'm suddenly incredibly optimistic.

The second Taysom Hill is able he'll be the starter and Siemian will be relegated back to the backup role.

Agreed, but not sure Hill would be an upgrade at QB over Semian.

There's a reason why Siemian has only started one game since the 2017 season. Taysom has been groomed to be a starter in the Saints offense for several years now. Winston just happened to be a better option, but I am sure Payton sees Hill as clearly the best option moving forward.

100%. Bucs D started to figure out Siemian in the 2nd half. I think Taysom will surprise us.

If you don’t think Hill will be easy to figure your crazy. Big difference coming in to run some razzle dazzle stuff once in a while versus running an offense for 4 quarters. It I’m sure Payton will put him at starter

Should I start a poll?

Hill as the starting QB doesn't make sense. Especially since he thrives in that jack-of-all-trades role (The man has blocked punts on special teams!) I love Taysom Hill but the fumbles are too much. Siemian is the right choice for Saints QB.


Should I start a poll?

There's a reason why Siemian has only started one game since the 2017 season. Taysom has been groomed to be a starter in the Saints offense for several years now. Winston just happened to be a better option, but I am sure Payton sees Hill as clearly the best option moving forward.