New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com

New Orleans Saints Forums - blackandgold.com (https://blackandgold.com/community/)
-   Saints (https://blackandgold.com/saints/)
-   -   Turning Attention to the Draft (https://blackandgold.com/saints/104421-turning-attention-draft.html)

WillSaints81 04-11-2025 06:39 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hitta (Post 1008791)
I would not take Shedeur Sanders. I don't see it from what I've observed, and he's challenging to evaluate because he's thrown so many short passes.

He's not the kind of QB I root for.

turbo_dog 04-12-2025 10:07 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
I don't see how Sanders gets past the Browns, honestly. They have Deshaun Watson and Kenny Picket as the current QBs. No way either of those two are a franchise QB at this point.

AsylumGuido 04-12-2025 10:58 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillSaints81 (Post 1008816)
He's not the kind of QB I root for.

What is it exactly that you don't like?

voodooido 04-12-2025 11:47 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
With the newly released news on Carrs injury I see it being more likely Dart is picked at 9. Might as well pull the trigger instead of delaying it until next year

rezburna 04-12-2025 12:03 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 1008810)
Most NFL ready QB in the draft from what I have been hearing.

https://twitter.com/nick_underhill/s...35037668331968

It's crazy seeing who rises and falls in pre-draft rankings. Shough had a lackluster college career and is 25 years old. I really hope we don't F this up. If Sanders is the pick at 9, perfect. If you really like Dart then trade down and get him in a more suitable spot. If not them build the interior, grab some weapons, and let Rattler play.

BakoSaint 04-12-2025 12:14 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by voodooido (Post 1008839)
With the newly released news on Carrs injury I see it being more likely Dart is picked at 9. Might as well pull the trigger instead of delaying it until next year

The Chiefs first pick in the 2016 NFL draft was Chris Jones. The top QB on the board when they made that pick was Christian Hackenberg. In that case, I think it paid off to delay it until next year. You have to believe in the player and see the value versus the alternatives available. Realistically the Saints are more than a year away and have many needs, with a much worse roster and cap situation than the 2016 Chiefs, so clearly they can wait if they need to.

voodooido 04-13-2025 08:02 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BakoSaint (Post 1008844)
The Chiefs first pick in the 2016 NFL draft was Chris Jones. The top QB on the board when they made that pick was Christian Hackenberg. In that case, I think it paid off to delay it until next year. You have to believe in the player and see the value versus the alternatives available. Realistically the Saints are more than a year away and have many needs, with a much worse roster and cap situation than the 2016 Chiefs, so clearly they can wait if they need to.

I would love a BPA but who do you suggest we enter the season with? I’m not sold on Rattler. Dart, imo, is the best in the draft. Any vets left out thrre?

K Major 04-13-2025 09:22 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Tyler Shough’s (Louisville QB) collegiate injury history would take him off my board.

Saints cannot afford to miss on this draft.

SmashMouth 04-13-2025 10:26 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Saints aren't going anywhere this year, even if we had a HOF coach at the helm. We'll be back with a top ten pick next year also, IMHO. Is there a QB in this year's crop or next year's that is an NFL starter and is of franchise quality, and that's any better than our question mark in the Bayou Rattler?

Settling for whoever QB after Cam is riddled with question marks, IMHO. If that's the case, as Kmajor, says, we need dogs that can play right away and for a long time. Draft beef on both sides. Howard can be had in the 3rd round. His numbers are improving if you look at his record in the past two years. And he's Josh Allen big and has some of his running skills if need be. I'd be OK rolling with Rattler, Howard and if need be Haener as 3rd string.

Shedeur showed decent versus subpar competition. He may be able to step up to the big league, or he may not. He can't hold on to the ball like he's shown so far. So is he a project at #9 is a valid concern? If he is, he has to be a hard pass, and let some other team deal with the Sanders press drama. Was Colorado a college playoff team?

Ask yourself, which college QB showed poise in the clutch?

If anything last year showed us, injuries at the OL killed us. We cannot have turnstiles protecting whoever the QB is going to be. We need new beef at OC and G and OT too. If both OTs are gone at #9, we can get the best OC or the best G or the best DL.

There is no JD5 in the draft this year, IMHO. Maybe next year, but it's too early to speculate. Or is it?

2025 NFL QB Draft Prospects

Who's there in 2026?



jnormand 04-13-2025 11:30 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
There’s some writers out there saying that Sanders wants to do his own thing and doesn’t want “marching orders” so to speak. That’s what he’s been kind of telling teams I guess? That’s his honesty he talks about.

IMO Sanders is a reach at 9 and is only benefiting from a poor QB draft. I’m not saying he’s not NFL talent, but top 10? Plus you gotta deal with his daddy? Good grief. Not at 9.

I’m with Smash. Roll with Rattler. Trade down and get some trench warriors. Get younger on defense.

Sanders isn’t going to bring a Lombardi to NOLA.

CheramieIII 04-13-2025 04:41 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 1008808)
Who is that? :confused:

Ward!

SmashMouth 04-14-2025 04:46 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 

spkb25 04-15-2025 04:53 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
If smart they would trade down(if available) get dart and an online.

K Major 04-15-2025 03:39 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Will Johnson - CB
Michigan

Strengths

- Big, smooth and instinctive.
- Presses with patient feet and strong re-routes.
- Connects quickly from press and can run with the route.
- Good body control and change of direction in space.
- Pre-snap play recognition makes it seem like he was in the offensive huddle.

Pro comparison- Jaycee Horn

Will has 1st rd grades throughout.

AsylumGuido 04-15-2025 03:50 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008883)
Will Johnson - CB
Michigan

Strengths

- Big, smooth and instinctive.
- Presses with patient feet and strong re-routes.
- Connects quickly from press and can run with the route.
- Good body control and change of direction in space.
- Pre-snap play recognition makes it seem like he was in the offensive huddle.

Pro comparison- Jaycee Horn

Will has 1st rd grades throughout.

Just heard on NFL Radio's Moving the Chains that he still hasn't run a 40 and that his short shuttle times were slower than those of elite CB's. They did say his tape was impressive but the size (6'3" +) is there and that he fits more of the Pete Carroll mold from the Legion of Boom days.

rezburna 04-15-2025 06:00 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 1008885)
Just heard on NFL Radio's Moving the Chains that he still hasn't run a 40 and that his short shuttle times were slower than those of elite CB's. They did say his tape was impressive but the size (6'3" +) is there and that he fits more of the Pete Carroll mold from the Legion of Boom days.

If we move to a more zone heavy scheme he's perfect for it. If we're still going to be man heavy then there are better fits. He'd be perfect somewhere like Philly, so if we adopt that style of defense he's going to be an All-Pro one day.

SmashMouth 04-15-2025 06:11 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rezburna (Post 1008887)
If we move to a more zone heavy scheme he's perfect for it. If we're still going to be man heavy then there are better fits. He'd be perfect somewhere like Philly, so if we adopt that style of defense he's going to be an All-Pro one day.

What if we play a 9-1-1 defense? Blitz every down and leave one in the backfield like Alontae.

Rugby Saint II 04-16-2025 09:41 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008762)
Walter Nolen - DT
Ole Miss (A&M transfer)

SCOUTING REPORT: STRENGTHS
Explosive first step off the snap allows him to consistently beat offensive linemen into their set and dictate initial engagement - shows up repeatedly against both run and pass
Natural leverage winner who plays with outstanding pad level and core strength, allowing him to control the point of attack and reset the line of scrimmage against single blocks

SCOUTING REPORT: WEAKNESSES
Can get caught playing too high at times, especially when fatigued late in games, allowing offensive linemen to get underneath his pads and control the point of attack

SCOUTING REPORT: SUMMARY

The tape shows a defender ready to make an immediate impact as a disruptive three-technique in an attacking front. Nolen's combination of first-step explosiveness, natural leverage, and refined technical skills will allow him to be a day-one starter in the NFL. His versatility to play multiple techniques along the defensive front adds significant value in today's multiple-front defenses.


No major injuries

As Smashmouth stated early, we need more beef in those trenches.

Late 1st, early 2nd round grades

Excellent!

Rugby Saint II 04-16-2025 09:43 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008775)
Giants (Russ will be 1 & done)
Jets (A Rod is gone)
Browns (always need a QB)

All ^^ draft ahead of the Saints & I’m not so sure they will all pass on Shadeur.

Ward is probably the first pick (Titans) taken.

Stranger things have happened on draft night though.

Our draft Day picks always make me nervous as hell!

Rugby Saint II 04-16-2025 09:47 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr.Riaton (Post 1008556)
If we don’t grab McMillan,we can take a chance on Savion Williams/ TCU. He has all the measurables you'd want in a wr and is oozing with potential.

HEIGHT: 6-4 WEIGHT: 222
HANDS: 10 1/4 ARM: 32 1/2
FORTY: 4.48
10YD: 1.52

Raw physical talent jumps off the tape with Williams, particularly in the vertical passing game where his combination of size and acceleration creates constant stress on defenses. The way he tracks deep balls shows natural instincts, while his development as a ball carrier displays impressive vision and feel. Yet his inconsistent hands and unrefined route breaks in the intermediate areas highlight the technical growth still needed in his game.

The ideal offensive system will build around Williams' strengths early while developing his complete game. A scheme that emphasizes play-action shots downfield and incorporates receivers into the run game would maximize his current abilities. His experience operating from different alignments and contributing in multiple phases opens creative possibilities, but he'll need clearly defined roles that expand as his route tree develops.

First-round talent with day-three polish makes Williams one of this draft's most fascinating evaluations. The gap between his elite athletic traits and technical refinement suggests a focused development plan will be crucial. While he might not be ready for a full route tree immediately, his ability to stress defenses vertically and create with the ball in his hands will demand defensive attention from day one. The foundation is there for a dynamic offensive weapon - he just needs time and coaching to reach that ceiling.

Looks to be available late day 2. Just gotta coach him up

We tried coaching them up in the past. That did not work out well! Hopefully, this new coaching staff actually knows how to coach.

rezburna 04-16-2025 10:30 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SmashMouth (Post 1008889)
What if we play a 9-1-1 defense? Blitz every down and leave one in the backfield like Alontae.

I grew up in a program that ran a hype aggressive 4-6 defense with both corners manned up, one safety playing center field, and everybody else blitzing. If you have the speed you can possibly do something like that from time to time. The Vikings like to run Cover 4 and blitz from that. I know you were joking but I like the idea of being blitz heavy and keeping everything in front of you.

K Major 04-16-2025 11:12 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Shadeur Sanders - QB
Colorado

Strengths
- Plays with confidence and composure from the pocket.
- Keeps his eyes downfield as the pocket compresses.
- Shows off ability to pump and reset when the play appears not to develop as he expected.
- Able to buy himself time and move his launch point when needed.
- Willing to stand in and take punishment when he gets locked in on the throw.
- Gets hips squared to the target on rollout throws.
- Steps into drive throws between the hashes and puts it on-frame.
- Allows routes to develop and throws with timing into zone windows.
- Hits receivers in stride and leads them into yards after the catch.
- Consistently accurate when he throws from a balanced platform.

Weaknesses
- Spacing and clearly defined route combinations make decision-making easier.
- Drops beyond proper pocket depth and into edge rusher’s path.
- Throws with a longer operation time.
- Has completions on tape that will be interceptions in the pros.

Draft projection - top 10 pick

voodooido 04-16-2025 01:26 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008909)
Shadeur Sanders - QB
Colorado

Strengths
- Plays with confidence and composure from the pocket.
- Keeps his eyes downfield as the pocket compresses.
- Shows off ability to pump and reset when the play appears not to develop as he expected.
- Able to buy himself time and move his launch point when needed.
- Willing to stand in and take punishment when he gets locked in on the throw.
- Gets hips squared to the target on rollout throws.
- Steps into drive throws between the hashes and puts it on-frame.
- Allows routes to develop and throws with timing into zone windows.
- Hits receivers in stride and leads them into yards after the catch.
- Consistently accurate when he throws from a balanced platform.

Weaknesses
- Spacing and clearly defined route combinations make decision-making easier.
- Drops beyond proper pocket depth and into edge rusher’s path.
- Throws with a longer operation time.
- Has completions on tape that will be interceptions in the pros.

Draft projection - top 10 pick

Sanders is not worthy of a top 20 pick. I say he falls to Pittsburgh

SmashMouth 04-16-2025 01:41 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008909)
Shadeur Sanders - QB
Colorado

Strengths
- Plays with confidence and composure from the pocket.
- Keeps his eyes downfield as the pocket compresses.
- Shows off ability to pump and reset when the play appears not to develop as he expected.
- Able to buy himself time and move his launch point when needed.
- Willing to stand in and take punishment when he gets locked in on the throw.
- Gets hips squared to the target on rollout throws.
- Steps into drive throws between the hashes and puts it on-frame.
- Allows routes to develop and throws with timing into zone windows.
- Hits receivers in stride and leads them into yards after the catch.
- Consistently accurate when he throws from a balanced platform.

Weaknesses
- Spacing and clearly defined route combinations make decision-making easier.
- Drops beyond proper pocket depth and into edge rusher’s path.
- Throws with a longer operation time.
- Has completions on tape that will be interceptions in the pros.

Draft projection - top 10 pick

A future interception machine is a top ten pick? :bugeyes:

K Major 04-16-2025 01:54 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SmashMouth (Post 1008913)
A future interception machine is a top ten pick? :bugeyes:

I don't see three QB “needy” teams passing on Sanders.

It’s all a crap shoot. No one knows how he will pan out.

K Major 04-16-2025 02:01 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Tyler Shough - QB
Louisville

Strengths
- Displays good command and full-field passing talent when protected.
- Adequate timing getting through his progressions.
- Effective use of eyes to hold linebackers and safeties.
- Splashy arm talent throws are all over his tape.


Weaknesses

- Sluggish operation time working quick-game throws.
- Lacks poise and mobility to overcome turbulent pockets.
- Occasional issues allowing routes to unwind and develop.
- Falls way off delivery when pressure is mounting in front of him.
- Gunslinger mentality brings occasional lapses in decision-making.
- Not enough “extend and win” when flushed from the pocket.
- Missed substantial time due to injury in 2021, 2022 and 2023.

Draft projection - Rd 2 or 3

Tyler will be 26 in September & has had a substantial injury history.

Based on injuries alone, he would be off of my draft board.

The Saints need immediate contributors.

SmashMouth 04-16-2025 02:28 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008915)
I don't see three QB “needy” teams passing on Sanders.

It’s all a crap shoot. No one knows how he will pan out.

The guy in the building, aka The Bayou Rattler, has arm strength to rival Brett Favre's. An NFL team today can't afford the kind of passer to rely on timing like a Shedeur and others like him. We have a Shedeur equivalent already in Pretty Boy Haener. We don't need another interception machine.

K Major 04-16-2025 03:13 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
I’m not so sure Rattler is that guy either.

iceshack149 04-16-2025 03:17 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008915)
I don't see three QB “needy” teams passing on Sanders.

It’s all a crap shoot. No one knows how he will pan out.

I hope the Saints draft d-line or o-line at 9 and stick with Rattler. Deion Sanders still worries me.

rezburna 04-16-2025 03:45 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by K Major (Post 1008918)
I’m not so sure Rattler is that guy either.

I like Rattler a lot. I really do. His arm talent is elite. He's matured so much over the years. I believe he'll be a starter in this league.

On the other hands...for all of those that miss the Drew Brees era...Sanders is going to be the closest thing to that. Not to mention the NFL is going to want him to succeed. It's good for the league and the bottom line.

If Sanders is off the board before 9 then I'm fine letting Rattler play out the season.

SmashMouth 04-16-2025 03:47 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rezburna (Post 1008920)
I like Rattler a lot. I really do. His arm talent is elite. He's matured so much over the years. I believe he'll be a starter in this league.

On the other hands...for all of those that miss the Drew Brees era...Sanders is going to be the closest thing to that. Not to mention the NFL is going to want him to succeed. It's good for the league and the bottom line.

If Sanders is off the board before 9 then I'm fine letting Rattler play out the season.

If it means the refs and RG cut us a break all the way to the SB for another Tiffany, then Hell Ya, let's all board the Shedeur Sanders train. :bng:

Mr.Riaton 04-16-2025 03:52 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
I believe Rattler has more to offer than people think. He only had a few games with second and third string oline and receiver and flashed some nice moments. He needs to be given a fair shot and put in some practices and a few games with the ones to really see what we have.

K Major 04-16-2025 04:19 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Jalon Walker - LB
Georgia

Strengths
- Hybrid talent who takes snaps as an off-ball linebacker and on the edge.
- Drifts downhill to meet blocks and constrict the run lane.
- Good length to stack blocks or punch and pass on the move.
- Twitched up with an elite closing burst to the football.
- Rush attack is highly athletic and very natural.
- Varies step cadence and entry angles, creating passivity from tackles.


Weaknesses
- Below-average size as a full-time edge defender.
- Improved off the ball but still developing his instincts.

Pro comparison - Nolan Smith

1st round projections throughout

turbo_dog 04-16-2025 09:07 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
I'm also high on the Rattler train. After all, he didn't play with the varsity squad last season. Still looked like a higher upside than Carr.

If the Saints take Sanders at 9, I'm ok. If they take someone later, cool. But like Rez said earlier, I don't think it should be Shough. I'm ok with Dart, Milroe, Howard, Riley in later rounds. Haven't really watched any of the guy from Syracuse

K Major 04-17-2025 11:05 AM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Azareye’h Thomas - CB
Florida State


Strengths
- Imposing size and length as a press corner.
- Stalls receiver’s release with a strong punch.
- Crowds and connects to the early stages of the route.
- Takes cues from receivers to turn, locate and play the throw.
- Seeks to occupy as much of the catch space as possible.
- Long arms are formidable weapons of catch disruption.

Round 2 projection

leilung 04-17-2025 12:16 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
I'm still anxious to get a top OL, preferably a LT so that we can get our stud, Fuaga back to his natural position on the RT! I really do believe that the quest for the next QB can wait, but without a line to give him thime, he's not going to be doing much except running for his life on most plays...

That being said: Sanders has had some of the most horrible lines in College Football since he's been playing. He could probably come in and do well right away with what we have.

AsylumGuido 04-17-2025 01:30 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Speaking of the draft, today I heard a pretty amazing bit of draft history. This year's first round, as it sits right now, is the first time since 1967 that every team in the league holds its own first round pick.

SmashMouth 04-17-2025 01:52 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by leilung (Post 1008939)
I'm still anxious to get a top OL, preferably a LT so that we can get our stud, Fuaga back to his natural position on the RT! I really do believe that the quest for the next QB can wait, but without a line to give him thime, he's not going to be doing much except running for his life on most plays...

That being said: Sanders has had some of the most horrible lines in College Football since he's been playing. He could probably come in and do well right away with what we have.

Easily forgotten is the speed difference in the NFL vs college. That's means he'll be a turnstile interception machine, in all likelihood.

K Major 04-17-2025 02:08 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SmashMouth (Post 1008941)
Easily forgotten is the speed difference in the NFL vs college. That's means he'll be a turnstile interception machine, in all likelihood.

Didn’t the scouts say that about Phills Simms & Favre coming out of college?

BakoSaint 04-17-2025 02:16 PM

Re: Turning Attention to the Draft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumGuido (Post 1008940)
Speaking of the draft, today I heard a pretty amazing bit of draft history. This year's first round, as it sits right now, is the first time since 1967 that every team in the league holds its own first round pick.

Interesting, I saw that somewhere too. Its a copycat league and I think the recent bust trades to move up for Trey Lance and Bryce Young among others discouraged other teams from trading up so much lately, making this possible. Ultimately I think most mega-deals have been busts (sometimes moving up a few spots at lesser compensation has worked out better) but these two trades going so bad so quickly at such a large scale of compensation really hit the nail in the coffin. At the same time trades of 1st round picks for elite veteran QBs have not gone so well lately either, with Russell Wilson and Aaron Rodgers being complete busts, and the Matthew Stafford being a bit murky since LA got the ring but then Goff became the better QB year 2 on. Trading 1st round picks may remain a cautionary tale until some team makes it work, more likely trading for a veteran given the challenges of a rookie handling the pressure of those expectations.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:53 AM.


Copyright 1997 - 2020 - BlackandGold.com